Appeals attorney sitting with client
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn

In commercial litigation, building a strong record for an appeal is an important, but often overlooked step. This process involves strategic planning to ensure that every piece of evidence and argument presented during the trial is accurately recorded. A well-prepared record can be the key to success in the appellate court, where decisions hinge on the thoroughness and clarity of the information provided. It is also about creating a comprehensive narrative that effectively communicates the strengths of your case to the appellate judges.

Understanding the Appeals Process

The appeals process in commercial litigation involves an appellate court reviewing the decision of a lower court. Unlike a trial, the appeal focuses not on the facts of the case but on the application of the law and procedural issues. The appellate court does not re-hear the case but evaluates whether legal errors occurred that could have affected the outcome. This is where the record, comprising all documents, evidence, and transcripts from the trial court, becomes pivotal. A well-prepared record allows the appellate court to scrutinize the legal aspects of the case thoroughly, making it a cornerstone of a successful appeal.

Key Elements of a Strong Record

  • Comprehensive Documentation: A strong record includes all relevant documents, such as pleadings, motions, court orders, and evidentiary exhibits. These materials should be organized chronologically and clearly labeled for easy reference by the appellate court.
  • Accurate Transcripts: Ensure that transcripts of hearings and trials are verbatim and error-free. They should capture all oral arguments, witness testimonies, and judicial rulings, providing a clear and complete picture of the proceedings.
  • Objective Evidence Presentation: The evidence should be presented objectively, highlighting its relevance and admissibility. This includes a clear demonstration of how the evidence supports legal arguments, ensuring the appellate court understands its significance in the context of the case.
  • Detailed Legal Arguments: Include well-articulated legal arguments and objections raised during the trial. This demonstrates the legal basis of your case and helps the appellate court identify potential errors in the application of the law.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

In building a record for appeal, one major misstep is incomplete documentation, where critical pieces of evidence or documents are omitted from the record. This oversight can hinder the appellate court’s ability to fully understand the issues on appeal. Another frequent error is poorly maintained or inaccurate trial transcripts. These are essential for appeals, and any discrepancies or omissions can be detrimental. Additionally, neglecting to preserve objections or failing to articulate legal arguments clearly during the trial can lead to challenges in raising these issues on appeal. Avoiding these mistakes is crucial for ensuring your appeal.

Strategies for Building a Strong Record

Building a strong record on appeal requires a proactive and detail-oriented approach. Start by ensuring all documents, evidence, and legal motions are carefully compiled. Work closely with court reporters to guarantee that trial transcripts are accurate and complete. Throughout the trial, be vigilant in preserving objections and making a clear record of any potential errors or issues for appeal. This includes specifically noting your objections and the reasons for them on the record. Engage in thorough legal research to back your arguments and ensure they are cogently presented. Finally, consider consulting with appellate specialists early in the process to strategize and identify key issues that might be critical for the appeal.

How We Can Help

At The Keleher Appellate Law Group, LLC, we are dedicated to guiding you through the complexities of the appeals process. Our team’s experience in crafting comprehensive records ensures your case is presented with precision and clarity. We invite you to reach out to us for personalized assistance to secure a favorable outcome in your commercial litigation appeal.

About the Author
Christopher Keleher clerked for the Hon. William J. Bauer of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.  This unique opportunity provided Mr. Keleher with an invaluable understanding of the inner workings of an appellate court.  He saw what persuades judges and what does not, and utilizes this knowledge every time he writes an appellate brief. The Keleher Appellate Law Group handles all phases of appellate litigation in federal and state courts across the country. Read more here.