Lady discussing business appeals in her company
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn

Appealing a business tort case in Illinois is a multistep process where appellate know-how will make a significant difference in the outcome. Common pitfalls, such as missing deadlines or misinterpreting the grounds for appeal, will impact the case outcome. The appeal process demands scrutiny and strategic planning to correct errors from the trial, ensuring your appeal is presented effectively.

Misunderstanding the Grounds for Appeal

When appealing a business tort case, it is important to recognize that not every unfavorable decision is appeal-worthy. Appeals address legal errors from the trial, not simply to contest the outcome. Understanding this distinction is key to determining whether your case has a viable basis for appeal.

Overlooking the Standard of Review

Understanding the standard of review is essential in appellate proceedings. This standard dictates how the appellate court will evaluate the lower court’s decision, ranging from de novo review, which allows for a fresh examination of all aspects, to more deferential standards that respect the trial court’s discretion. A clear understanding allows for strategic framing of your appeal, focusing on arguments that align with how the court will assess the evidence and rulings from the trial phase.

Failing to Preserve Issues for Appeal

An important step in the appeal process is ensuring that potential issues are properly raised and preserved at trial. If certain arguments or objections are not presented at this stage, they are precluded on appeal. This requires a proactive approach during trial to document and challenge any legal missteps, safeguarding the opportunity to address these issues in the appellate court.

Inadequate Record on Appeal

An adequate record is necessary for a successful appeal. This comprehensive documentation includes all relevant trial transcripts, evidence, and motions. If the appellate record lacks crucial information, it hampers the ability to argue your case effectively on appeal. Ensuring that the record fully captures the trial proceedings is essential, as the appellate court relies on this record to review the case.

Poorly Drafted Appellate Briefs

The quality of an appellate brief will influence the appeal. A well-crafted brief articulates clear arguments, cites relevant legal precedents and persuasively argues the case for overturning the trial court’s decision. Conversely, a poorly drafted brief can fail to highlight key issues or persuade the appellate judges and may undermine the appeal’s effectiveness. Attention to detail and a compelling argument will strengthen your appellate brief.

Not Understanding the Impact of Precedent

The role of legal precedent in shaping appellate outcomes cannot be understated. These prior judicial decisions guide appellate courts in interpreting and applying the law to current cases. A lack of understanding about relevant precedents can weaken an appeal, as it fails to align arguments with established legal standards. Thorough research and strategic use of precedent will make an argument that resonates with appellate judges.

Underestimating the Costs and Duration of an Appeal

Many appellants underestimate the financial and time commitments required for an appeal. The appellate process is lengthy, often taking months or even years, and involves significant legal expenses, from filing fees to attorney fees. A realistic assessment of these factors is crucial before proceeding, as it affects both the strategy and the decision to appeal. Understanding the potential duration and costs helps set appropriate expectations and prepare for the journey ahead.

Choosing the Wrong Legal Representation

Selecting the right legal representation is paramount for a successful appeal. An attorney with specific experience in appellate law and familiarity with business tort cases in Illinois and federal appellate courts can make a substantial difference. The wrong choice might lead to missed opportunities and overlooked details critical for your appeal. It’s recommended to choose a lawyer who not only understands the complexities of appellate procedures but also aligns with your case’s unique needs and goals.

At the Keleher Appellate Law Group, we are committed to guiding you through the appellate process, transforming trial-level challenges into opportunities for appeal success. Our dedicated team understands the nuances of your case and is ready to provide the support you need. Contact us today to explore how we can assist in securing a positive result for your appeal.

About the Author
Christopher Keleher clerked for the Hon. William J. Bauer of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.  This unique opportunity provided Mr. Keleher with an invaluable understanding of the inner workings of an appellate court.  He saw what persuades judges and what does not, and utilizes this knowledge every time he writes an appellate brief. The Keleher Appellate Law Group handles all phases of appellate litigation in federal and state courts across the country. Read more here.